Crater Lake National Park vs Shenandoah National Park

Feel Free To Share:

Crater Lake National Park vs Shenandoah National Park

“Discover the beauty of two American treasures: Crater Lake National Park and Shenandoah National Park. While both parks offer stunning landscapes, they each have a unique character that makes them truly special. Crater Lake, nestled in Oregon, is a breathtaking sight with its deep blue lake formed in the crater of an extinct volcano, surrounded by dramatic cliffs and dense forests. Shenandoah, located in Virginia, is a rolling landscape of hills and mountains, dotted with cascading waterfalls and scenic overlooks, perfect for a scenic drive or a peaceful hike. Whether you’re seeking serenity in nature or an adrenaline rush on the trails, these two parks promise to leave you in awe and yearning for more.”

Hiking Trails in Crater Lake National Park and Shenandoah National Park

Crater Lake and Shenandoah National Parks offer diverse hiking experiences. Crater Lake’s trails range from easy lakeside walks to strenuous backcountry treks, including the Rim Drive, Rim Trail, Garfield Peak, and Cleetwood Cove Trail, which descends steeply to the lake shore. Shenandoah has over 500 miles of trails, including easy hikes like Stony Man Trail and tougher ones like Old Rag Mountain, a strenuous and rocky hike to the summit, and Dark Hollow Falls Trail, which descends to a 70-ft waterfall.

Most Popular Hiking Trails in Crater Lake National Park

Name Length Elevation Type Difficulty Visitor Ratings
Garfield Peak Trail 5471.756 325.8312 Moderate out and back 4.5
Cleetwood Cove Trail 3379.614 189.8904 Moderate out and back 4.5
The Watchman Peak Trail 2574.944 117.9576 Moderate out and back 4.5
Mount Scott Trail 6759.228 383.7432 Moderate out and back 4.5
Discovery Point Trail 6437.36 278.892 Easy out and back 4.5
Plaikni Falls Trail 3218.68 40.8432 Easy out and back 4
Wizard Island Trail 3701.482 228.9048 Moderate loop 4.5
Sun Notch Trail 1287.472 38.7096 Easy loop 4.5
Pinnacles Valley Trail 1126.538 11.8872 Easy out and back 4
Mazama Village to Rim Village at Crater Lake 13357.522 530.9616 Moderate out and back 4.5

Most Popular Hiking Trails in Shenandoah National Park

Name Length Elevation Type Difficulty Visitor Ratings
Old Rag Mountain Loop 13840.324 736.7016 Hard loop 5
White Oak Canyon and Cedar Run Trails Loop 14484.06 722.9856 Hard loop 4.5
Dark Hollow Falls Trail 2253.076 171.9072 Moderate out and back 4.5
Bearfence Mountain Trail 1609.34 73.7616 Moderate loop 4.5
Hawksbill Gap Loop via Appalachian Trail 4184.284 228.9048 Moderate loop 4.5
Rose River Trail 5632.69 256.9464 Moderate loop 4.5
White Oak Canyon Trail 15288.73 733.9584 Hard out and back 4.5
Stony Man via Appalachian Trail 2414.01 97.8408 Easy loop 4.5
South River Falls Trail 7402.964 387.7056 Moderate out and back 4.5
Little Stony Man Loop via Appalachian Trail 5471.756 263.9568 Moderate loop 4.5

Wildlife in Crater Lake National Park and Shenandoah National Park

Crater Lake NP & Shenandoah NP both offer unique wildlife experiences. Crater Lake is known for its sightings of deer, black bears, and the occasional mountain lion, along with bird species such as Steller’s jays, bald eagles, and ospreys. On the other hand, Shenandoah is known for its white-tailed deer, black bears, bobcats, foxes, and birds like red-tailed hawk, Baltimore oriole, and peregrine falcon. Both parks boast diverse and colorful plant life, including wildflowers, ferns, mosses, and tall trees like Douglas Fir and Redwoods.

Below are lists of the most commonly spotted wildlife at Crater Lake National Park and Shenandoah National Park. However, you can see a full list of wildlife at each national park here.

Birds

Crater Lake National Park Shenandoah National Park
Peregrine Falcon Peregrine Falcon
Northern Harrier Northern Harrier
Sharp-Shinned Hawk Sharp-Shinned Hawk
Osprey Osprey
Tree Swallow Tree Swallow
Mallard Mallard
Canada Goose Canada Goose
Lincoln’s Sparrow Lincoln’s Sparrow
Ruby-Crowned Kinglet Ruby-Crowned Kinglet
American Robin American Robin
Great Horned Owl Great Horned Owl
Red-Tailed Hawk Red-Tailed Hawk
Northern Flicker Northern Flicker
Merlin Merlin
Barn Swallow Barn Swallow
Savannah Sparrow Savannah Sparrow
Great Blue Heron Great Blue Heron
Hermit Thrush Hermit Thrush
Bald Eagle American Kestrel
Song Sparrow Bald Eagle
European Starling Song Sparrow
Northern Pintail European Starling
American Wigeon Northern Pintail
American Pipit American Wigeon
Swainson’s Thrush Green-Winged Teal

Mammals

Crater Lake National Park Shenandoah National Park
Coyote Coyote
American Beaver American Beaver
Muskrat Muskrat
Big Brown Bat Big Brown Bat
Bobcat Bobcat
Striped Skunk Striped Skunk
Little Brown Bat Little Brown Bat
Deer Mouse Deer Mouse
Raccoon Raccoon
Black Bear Black Bear
Porcupine Silver-Haired Bat
Silver-Haired Bat Hoary Bat
Hoary Bat Red Fox
Red Fox Long-Tailed Weasel
Long-Tailed Weasel House Mouse
House Mouse Mountain Lion
Mountain Lion Gray Fox
Mink River Otter
Mule Deer Or Black-Tailed Deer Masked Shrew
Gray Fox Water Shrew
Wolf Red Squirrel
Long-Legged Myotis White-Tailed Deer
Long-Eared Myotis Virginia Opossum
American Badger Marten
Ermine Northern Flying Squirrel

Fish

Crater Lake National Park Shenandoah National Park
Rainbow Trout Rainbow Trout
Brook Trout Brook Trout
Brown Trout Brown Trout
Lake Trout Largemouth Bass
Silver Salmon Green Sunfish
Kokanee Salmon Bluegill
Cutthroat Trout Common Carp
Mottled Sculpin
Longnose Dace
Yellow Bullhead
Creek Chub
Brown Bullhead
Smallmouth Bass

Reptiles

Crater Lake National Park Shenandoah National Park
Western Terestrial Garter Snake Black Racer
Racer Ringneck Snake
Sagebrush Lizard Common Garter Snake
Common Garter Snake Common Kingsnake
Rubber Boa Milksnake
Western Skink Eastern Fence Lizard
Western Fence Lizard

Amphibians

Crater Lake National Park Shenandoah National Park
Bullfrog Northern Leopard Frog

Insects

Crater Lake National Park Shenandoah National Park
Orange Sulphur Orange Sulphur
Painted Lady Painted Lady
Red Admiral Monarch
Honey Bee American Lady
Purplish Copper Red Admiral
Anise Swallowtail Mourning Cloak
Cabbage White
Silvery Blue
Common Checkered Skipper
Clouded Sulphur
Variegated Fritillary
Buckeye
Commom Wood Nymph
Gray Hairstreak

Beautiful Landscapes in Crater Lake National Park and Shenandoah National Park

Crater Lake NP is famous for its deep blue lake created in a volcanic caldera. Rim Drive provides scenic overlooks of the lake and surrounding park.

Shenandoah NP is known for Skyline Drive, rolling hills, and its numerous waterfalls. Hawksbill Mountain is the park’s highest point and offers panoramic views. Visitors can also hike scenic trails and stop at overlooks for views of the park’s mountains and valleys.

Things To-Do and Activities in Crater Lake National Park and Shenandoah National Park

Crater Lake NP and Shenandoah NP offer unique outdoor experiences for visitors. Crater Lake is known for its stunning blue waters, scenic drives and boat tours, fishing, and hiking. Shenandoah has scenic drives, wildlife viewing, and fishing in addition to its extensive network of trails for hiking and horseback riding. Both parks offer scenic drives, but Shenandoah also has a section of the Appalachian Trail, making it a destination for backpacking and camping.

Best Time to Visit Crater Lake National Park and Shenandoah National Park

Crater Lake NP in Oregon has dry, mild summers (40-70°F) & snowy winters (20-40°F). Shenandoah NP in Virginia has 4 seasons, with warm, humid summers (60-80°F), cold winters (20-40°F), and more precip. Crater Lake is best visited in summer for optimal weather and accessibility. Shenandoah is best visited year-round, with peak in fall for foliage.

Family Friendliness of Crater Lake National Park and Shenandoah National Park

Both Crater Lake and Shenandoah are family-friendly, but each offers different experiences. Crater Lake offers stunning lake views, fishing, hiking and boat tours. Shenandoah has 500+ miles of trails, including scenic drives, camping, picnicking and wildlife viewing. It depends on individual preferences, but both parks offer natural beauty and activities for families.

Leave a Comment